Help small businesses bounce back faster by recovering money on complex workers’ compensation and commercial auto claims. This fully remote subrogation role lets you own a focused caseload, drive recoveries, and directly impact claim cost containment.
About Pie Insurance
Pie Insurance is a tech driven commercial insurance company on a mission to make coverage affordable and as easy as pie for small businesses. They use data, automation, and a customer first mindset to rethink how small businesses buy and experience insurance. As part of the claims team, you’ll help protect those businesses by identifying, pursuing, and securing subrogation recoveries that keep costs under control.
Schedule
- Full time, remote role based anywhere in the United States (territories excluded).
- Standard weekday business hours with collaboration across claims and internal partners.
- Requires reliable, high speed internet and a dedicated, professional home workspace.
What You’ll Do
- Investigate subrogation opportunities by securing new evidence and information across all applicable lines of business.
- Determine potential subrogation recovery amounts and build a clear recovery strategy for each assigned file.
- Evaluate liability and conduct additional investigation as needed to reach optimal settlements.
- Collaborate with front line adjusters to align on case strategy, share new facts, and reassess liability and settlement options.
- Issue subrogation notices in line with state specific regulations and company standards.
- Maintain proactive contact with insureds, claimants, carriers, attorneys, adverse parties, and internal adjusters to move recovery efforts forward.
- Document action plans, investigations, negotiations, and recovery status clearly in claim notes and systems.
- Negotiate workers’ compensation and commercial auto subrogation claims with carriers and other responsible parties, including attorneys and legal reps.
- Assist with the recovery of claim overpayments and negotiate lien/settlement amounts based on case facts.
What You Need
- At least 2 years of experience handling workers’ compensation and/or commercial auto claims subrogation.
- Strong understanding of insurance claim procedures and subrogation workflows.
- Strong written and verbal communication skills with a professional, clear style.
- Confident decision making and critical thinking skills in a fast paced environment.
- Strong negotiation skills with experience settling or resolving disputed liability and damages.
- Ability to learn quickly, take ownership of new responsibilities, and manage a steady caseload.
- Comfort working both independently and as part of a collaborative claims team.
- Experience with G Suite tools, Microsoft Office, and common collaboration platforms.
- High school diploma or GED required; bachelor’s degree preferred.
Benefits
- Base salary range of 70,000 to 90,000 dollars per year, depending on experience and location.
- Competitive cash compensation plus equity so you truly get “a piece of the pie.”
- Comprehensive health plans.
- Generous paid time off.
- Future focused 401k match.
- Generous parental and caregiver leave.
Subrogation roles that blend autonomy, impact on claim outcomes, and fully remote flexibility are not common.
If you’re ready to own your recoveries and help small businesses thrive, this one deserves serious consideration.
Happy Hunting,
~Two Chicks…